Join the conversation

...about what is working in our public schools.

Who's Coming to the Party?

vonzastrowc's picture

If you have any doubts about the need for good civics education, then read this. David Barstow's account of troubling undercurrents in the Tea Party movement shows us just how precarious the fate of our civil society can be.

And lest people think I'm singling out certain Tea Partiers unfairly, I'll extend the critique to anyone on the left or right who flings about words like tyranny or fascism any time they encounter an opposing political view. It's all too easy to paint those we disagree with as traitors to the American cause.

It's not enough to swear fealty to the Constitution. We have to sustain and build institutions where people with different views work together to tackle common problems. And we have to nourish better civic habits in our young people. We shouldn't leave people to discover the nation's founding documents for the first time when they feel a grievance or sense that the world is changing around them. We have much to worry about if Americans get their first taste of civic action in a climate of fear and anger.

Tell me--Am I right to worry?


This is hardly a party-line

This is hardly a party-line political problem. I wouldn't call it "tyranny." But I would call it "traiterous." It's a far better description of what this unchecked spending is doing to our nation.

I voted Ron Paul in the primaries because I can acknowledge the financial times in which we live. I'm sorry more people didn't do the same. Then again, I was doing the freakout dance about deficit spending back in the 80's... you know, when I first learned this concept of "negative numbers" and "interest." I learned about "negative numbers" from my public school experience. I only wish they taught me about "interest." But at least I learned. :)

This Poli Sci major/former

This Poli Sci major/former journalist absolutely tears out his hair over this.

While I absolutely find our civics education lacking at the K12 level (this was one of the reasons I was attracted to teaching actually), I am more worried about the echo-chamber-of-stupid that is our television media. When folks get their civics education in pithy, hysterical screaming on TV for hours a week, we shouldn't be surprised when voters are operating at that level.

Course, the Tea Party crowd would likely not trust the institution of schools to take the lead with that education.

Mrs. C--I agree that this is

Mrs. C--I agree that this is not a party-line problem. (Hence my attempt at a broad critique.) People of all political stripes have been screaming about the enemy within and sinister plots by politicians or people of opposing parties to undo everything that made us great. There's little room for civil society to function when those kinds of conversations set the standard.

Mr. Brown--I agree about the level of discourse on television--and what a terrible stand-in that is for proper civic education. If people don't trust schools to undertake civic education, do they trust Olbermann or Hannity to do the job?

*Trust* public schools to

*Trust* public schools to undertake civic education?

Claus is sitting there wondering what my response would be to that little gem, aren't ya, Claus? :P

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options