Join the conversation

...about what is working in our public schools.

Hooray for Mono-Tasking

vonzastrowc's picture

Multi-tasking might not be all it's cracked up to be. So perhaps schools should do all they can to nurture students' mono-tasking skills.

ASCD's In-Service blog sums up a few of Richard Restak's concerns about multi-tasking. Two stand out for me:

  • "The more you multitask, the worse you do those tasks and the more distractible you become."
  • "Those who do too much multitasking often have trouble distinguishing relevant from irrelevant information."

Restak is one of a handful of authors and researchers who have been sounding alarm bells about kids' apparent need to do ten things at once. A few years ago, Walter Kim argued that people who do too many things at once lose their ability to retain information.

People tend to knock schools for for resisting new technologies and forcing children to conform to old models of schooling. But maybe schools should hold fast to a few decidedly anti-modern principles. Sustained attention and reflection don't always get their due these days.

I'm not a Luddite.* I think it's insane to lock school doors against new technologies. Many hold immense promise for teaching and learning. Young people, who are awash in new media, shouldn't have to step back in time to go to school. They'll need to learn to use technology well.

And that's why mono-tasking still deserves a place of honor in our schools. When so many things are constantly vying for our attention, we need the ability to one thing at a time.

That, too, is an important skill.


I have a tendency to

I have a tendency to multi-task, particularly information and communication. For example, at the moment I am listening to my wife's random comments as I shift between Tweetdeck, and responding to this article. It is better if I concentrate on creative activities like responding to this article. A momentary distraction, such as explaining the nature of my activity to my wife, will disrupt the flow of thought. I write a little. When I was a young father I learned to do this as I watched my children. As time passed, I lost that knack. Likely Zastrow is focussed on this form of multi-tasking and I think the point is well taken. I have silent reading each day so my students can mono-task reading.

We are champions of multi-tasking in schools and the school day distracts. It takes me almost half an hour to fully immerse myself in creative writing. Two uninterrupted hours become very productive. We never offer students this opportunity. We fragment their days and shift them by the clock. I am constantly either throwing out my schedule or dragging young people away from some problem or project in which they have become deeply engaged. It always feels wrong. I am discouraged that our division's one high school using the copernican system (two classes each term) ended the program. It made sense to me.

A case might be made for multi-tasking. People can immerse themselves for different periods of time. Stepping away from a problem for a fragment of time can serve to moderate stress. Many tasks simply do not warrant mono-tasking. Certainly education has examples of this. It probably depends on the primary activity of importance.

I agree

I agree 100%

blackjack
roulette

just take things slowly and

just take things slowly and one at a time that will make more efficient and productive great site really informative i learned a lot great stuff keep it up

Look at

Look at THIS:

http://hammie-hammiesays.blogspot.com/2010/04/i-want-your-iphone.html

Isn't that great? On the other hand, I troll my son's facebook account and can tell you who is updating during math class and threatening ex-friends for stealing boyfriends. Drama! They used to pass notes for that kind of thing, but now little do these tweenies know that oldsters like me know EVERYTHING about them. Bwa ha haaaaa.

PS Did you read about the principal who urged parents not to allow their kids to have facebook?

Alan--I suspect you're right.

Alan--I suspect you're right.  Sometimes we have to multi-task. Sometimes we have to mono-task. We have to know how to do both well. I find I have to multi-task a great deal in my job, and sometimes it seems harder than it ever was to focus on one thing for an expended period of time. That, it seems to me, is a loss.

"Essays"--thanks for the comment. Sorry I deleted your link to the free essay mill. That sort of thing kind of gets under educators' skin, you see....

Mrs. C--Great blog post. Thanks for the link. Thanks for reminding me about the more positive aspects of Facebook--secret monitoring! I haven't heard about the principal who has urged parents to prohibit Facebook, but I'm not surprised that it would happen somewhere. Seems like a fruitless attempt--and kids will have to learn to use it responsibly and for good. It doesn't make sense to banish social networking. (But then again, I'm not in that principal's shoes!)

Here's the link on the

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options