High Standards or Double Standards?
Fewer than half of students in Boston charter high schools make it to graduation. That's the bottom line of a union-sponsored study of the city's charters.
Charter leaders don't deny the numbers, but they do deny consciously pushing students out of their schools. It's those doggone high standards that are to blame! According to the Boston Globe:
Many students, charter leaders said, choose to leave to dodge high academic standards, returning to city-run schools where getting a diploma is often easier. Only in rare circumstances, they said, did a charter student quit school without subsequently earning a diploma.
“We are not just handing out diplomas,’’ said Thabiti Brown, principal at Codman Academy Charter Public School in Dorchester. “We want students to be successful in college, but unfortunately we have students who leave because they feel our academic standards are too high."
Is it me, or is there a double standard here? Shouldn't education reform zealots, for the sake of consistency, accuse Principal Brown of heresy? After all, he seems to believe that some children can't learn to high standards. Shouldn't a "no excuses" school do "whatever it takes" to hold on to each and every student, regardless of how unmotivated or intimidated by high standards? I though only "establishment" educators made excuses.
More to the point.... How can we say charter schools are better than traditional public schools if charters can't hold on to less motivated, less accomplished students? How can charter proponents claim that charter schools are the answer to what ails education? What should traditional public schools do with students who, in Principal Brown's words, "feel the academic standards are too high?" Push them down the road to an easier school? How does that leave no child behind?
Brown is by all accounts a devoted and uncommonly gifted educator. Codman Academy is likely an excellent school. But it struggles with attrition, a problem that bedevils some of the country's best charter schools. (In traditional public schools, another term for attrition is "dropout rate.") As Mike Petrilli noted some time ago, many charter operators are realizing that the reality of urban school reform does not always match the rhetoric.
So zealots should stop pushing charters as the final word in urban school reform. It's one thing to say that some charter schools offer motivated students an excellent learning environment. It's quite another to argue that they're the magic pill for urban education.
Charters and traditional schools face many of the same challenges. But we all know what happens to traditional public school principals who use high standards to justify attrition.
School reforms that improve the lives of all kids cannot rest on charters alone.
Update: Carolyn Hoxby's new study of New York City charter schools finds that, on average, they substantially outperform traditional public schools. Hoxby concludes that students in remain in New York City charters from first to eighth grades actually perform almost as well as their peers in affluent schools. Her study compares students in charter schools with those who applied to charters but were not accepted. This methodology aims to minimize the effects of selection bias.
The study presents a strong endorsement of the city's charter schools as an important option for motivated students and families. I'm not sure it addresses the impact of attrition, however. Nor does it present charters as the solution for all children. Still, it seems to support the role of charters as laboratories for innovations we can apply in traditional public schools.
Click here to browse dozens of Public School Insights interviews with extraordinary education advocates, including:
- National PTA President Otha Thornton on the Common Core
- 2013 School Counselor of the Year Mindy Willard on the state of her profession
- Supervisor of Administration John Swang on saving money in energy costs
The views expressed in this website's interviews do not necessarily represent those of the Learning First Alliance or its members.
Excellence is the Standard
At Pierce County High School in rural southeast Georgia, the graduation rate has gone up 31% in seven years. Teachers describe their collaboration as the unifying factor that drives the school’s improvement. Learn more...
- AACTE's Ed Prep Matters
- ISTE Connects
- PTA's One Voice
- PDK Blog
- The EDifier
- School Board News Today
- Legal Clips
- Learning Forward’s PD Watch
- NAESP's Principals' Office
- NASSP's Principal's Policy Blog
- The Principal Difference
- ASCA Scene
- Always Something
- NSPRA: Social School Public Relations
- Transforming Learning
- AASA's The Leading Edge
- AASA Connects (formerly AASA's School Street)
- NEA Today
- Angles on Education
- Lily's Blackboard
What Else We're Reading
- DQC's The Flashlight
- Center for Teaching Quality
- The Answer Sheet
- Politics K-12
- U.S. Department of Education Blog
- John Wilson Unleashed
- The Core Knowledge Blog
- This Week in Education
- Inside School Research
- Teacher Leadership Today
- On the Shoulders of Giants
- Teacher in a Strange Land
- Teach Moore
- The Tempered Radical
- The Educated Reporter
- Taking Note
- Character Education Partnership Blog
- Why I Teach